Disclaimer: I do not own The Vampire Diaries. I do not make any money from the writing of this story.
Author's note: This story takes place after Episode 19 of Series 4 and contains spoilers.
Keywords: Anal, BDSM, DP, FFFF, Oral, Toys
Vampire Diaries: Frustrating Part 6
by MTL ([email protected])
Rebekah Mikaelson couldn't remember the last time she had been this happy. In fact, she wasn't sure if she had ever been this happy. The reasons for this were numerous, but ironically the most important one was Elena Gilbert. Specifically the fact that Elena Gilbert was her date to prom, the two of them the centre of attention during this extremely human experience, which in turn made Rebekah feel more human than she had in years. And really, who needed a sodding cure when she had this woman in her arms, both of them dressed to impress and the talk of the entire party.
Of course no matter how hard she tried to block it out Rebekah could hear most of it, and knew there was a lot of catty/homophobic bull-shit, but for every comment she could see just as much jealousy from just about everyone in the room. Some were jealous of their expensive clothes and/or the attention they were receiving, others secretly wanted to be in Elena's place or hers and some were even envious of their happiness. Rebekah couldn't blame them for that, even though she knew deep down that Elena was playing into it, hanging off of her and whispering into her ear.
Elena was probably looking to shock her friends and all the people who thought they knew her. Boy crazy Elena Gilbert dancing with a girl, sitting with a girl, kissing a girl. Rebekah particularly enjoyed that last one, although she had to admit, she enjoyed the rest of it. She had always had a flair for the dramatic, her entire family did, but this was quite the little scandal Rebekah had found herself in. It was easily the most fun and the biggest which didn't include bloodshed.
But of course there was someone there to rain on her parade, "She'll never love you, you know that right?"
Turning around Rebekah sighed at the witch in front of her, "What?"
"Elena. Without her humanity she's incapable of it." Bonnie Bennett pointed out, "Of course, if you really cared about her you would compel her to turn her humanity back on. That way she can get over Jeremy-"
"Oh, like you're doing such a good job." Elena interrupted, "Tell me Bonnie, just how many times a day do you visit his grave?"
Bonnie closed her eyes, took a breath and opened them again before she continued like she hadn't been interrupted, "She can grieve properly, like a normal person, then maybe when all this is over she'll choose you."
"Yeah right." Elena laughed, before leaning into Rebekah's ear, "You remember the old Elena, don't you Rebekah? The one that hated you? The one you killed? The one that was so in love with Damon, or Stefan depending on what time of day it was? Do you really think she could ever love you?"
"You know I'm right." Bonnie said softly.
There was a long silence, then Rebekah focused on Bonnie and pointed out, "Since when do you care about me?"
"I don't, but at least I'm not pretending like her." Bonnie said.
"Oh, it's no act. I do like her." Elena smirked.
"But you don't love her." Bonnie pointed out.
Elena shrugged, "Love is fleeting. It makes you weak and stupid. I think Rebekah likes the alternative, don't you baby?"
The two of them just stared at each other for a second, then Rebekah turned back to Bonnie, "Elena has treated me better like this than anyone."
"Wow, that's really sad." Bonnie quipped.
"Do you have a bloody point." Rebekah growled.
Bonnie sighed, and turned to Elena, "Where's Caroline?"
"And the truth comes out." Elena giggled, "See sweetie, the big bad Witch is just trying to tear us apart."
"Well, we'll just have to return the favour then." Rebekah grinned evilly.
"I'm not afraid if you." Bonnie said.
"You should be." Elena practically purred.
Gritting her teeth Bonnie pointed out, "That, is Caroline's dress, she isn't answering my calls, and after earlier I just... what did you bitches do? Where is she?"
Rebekah shrugged, "She's a little tied up at the moment."
"With a butt-plug up her ass." Elena added with a giggle.
Rebekah joined her girlfriend in her laughter as they watched a horrifying looking Bonnie Bennett turned to leaving in a hurry, Elena dragging The Original back out on the dancefloor for more scandalous close quarters dancing which might as well have ended with them fucking each other right there in the middle of prom. Oh yes, this was going to be quite a night for Rebekah, one which made her indecently happy. And if Bonnie was smart, she'd be just as happy by the end of the night.
* * *
Bonnie wasn't sure what to believe. She knew she couldn't trust Rebekah, or sadly Elena at this point, and this could easily be a trap, but if it was there was nothing she could do but walk into it. Caroline wasn't returning her calls and she tried a locator spell three different times only to get the same results, that her best friend Caroline was trapped in Rebekah's mansion. She couldn't just leave her there to become the plaything of the psychotic vampires. So Bonnie cast one last spell to doublecheck there was only one person in the mansion, then she cautiously made her way inside.
The fact that the front door was unlocked was even more suspicious, but at least Bonnie's magic guided her straight to Caroline, where things were worse than she had suspected. Not only was Caroline gagged, blindfolded and tied to a bed, but she was completely naked, several long seconds ticking by as Bonnie stared in disbelief at her best friend trussed up like a fetish porn star or something. Then Bonnie became aware of something deep down inside her which terrified her. It also made the witch feel incredibly guilty, so she quickly freed Caroline's wrists and feet with a flick of her hand.
"Caroline, are you ok?" Bonnie asked softly, immediately hating herself for it because she knew the answer to that, and even worse following it up with, "Did they hurt you?"
Obviously Caroline wasn't ok, and of course those evil bitches had abused her. If it wasn't for vampire healing Bonnie would have probably seen marks covering the blonde's beautiful body, and the air definitely smelt of sex, Bonnie's stomach churning and yet somehow fluttering at the thought of her best friend being forced into lesbian sex by their former best friend and a 1000 year old vampire. It only got worse when Caroline removed her gag and blindfold, took one look at Bonnie and burst into tears, the witch scurrying over to the young vampire and cradling her in her arms.
"I'm so sorry sweetie." Bonnie cooed gently, stroking Caroline's hair, "I swear, I'll make them pay. Whatever they did to you, I'll make sure they regret it. But for now, we've got to get out of here, ok?"
"No." Caroline sniffled slightly, before lifting her head so she was face to face with Bonnie, "Not ok."
Bonnie frowned and opened her mouth to ask what Caroline was talking about, but before she could get the words out the other girl grabbed her face and kissed her hard. Her best friend, a girl she couldn't remember not knowing, forcefully pressed her lips against hers and shoved her tongue directly into her mouth, Bonnie so shocked that she just let it happen. Caroline even pressed her down against the bed sheets and still she did nothing. Worst of all, when she did finally do something, it wasn't push Caroline away. Oh no, she began kissing her back, something which Bonnie told herself was her body simply reacting of its own accord, although she couldn't quite believe it.
What could have been minutes or hours later Caroline broke the lip lock and started kissing the soft, vulnerable flesh of Bonnie's neck, finally prompting the witch to stammer, "Ca, Caroline! What are you doing?"
"Something I've secretly always wanted to do!" Caroline admitted with a grin against Bonnie's neck.
For a few moments Bonnie's mind raced, then she moaned, "Mmmmmmmmm, Caroline stop, ohhhhhhhhhh, you're not yourself. Rebekah, ohhhhhhhh, Rebekah must have compelled you to-"
"No she didn't! I want this! I want you!" Caroline said firmly once she had brought her face level with Bonnie's again, the blonde using her super speed to do that in the blink of an eye, and then again to slide her hand up the brunette's dress to rest against her panties, then Caroline grinned, "And I see I'm not the only one."
Blushing furiously Bonnie averted her gaze, "We... we can't. Not here, not now."
"Yes we can." Caroline pushed, undressing her friend in a second with her supernatural speed and then laying Bonnie back down so she could get on top of her.
Caroline used that same speed to quickly press a couple of kisses to her friend's chest, up one boob and then take a nipple into her mouth. After switching from licking and sucking on it for about a minute or so Caroline moved to the other nipple, the vampire repeating the process over and over again while to her delight the which seemed speechless. Then Bonnie opened her mouth again but Caroline beat her to the punch by biting down almost hard enough to break the skin, causing her friend to cry out in a mixture of pain and pleasure.
This process repeated a few times, Caroline constantly doing something to distract Bonnie. Mainly it was sucking and biting extra hard on Bonnie's nipples, one time succeeding in breaking the skin and the vampire eagerly lapping at the tiny bit of blood which escaped as a result before force-feeding her friend so the wound would heal itself. Ultimately though Bonnie found her voice again and started complaining about how they couldn't do this here, that she still wasn't convinced Caroline really wanted to do it, and yet never saying that she didn't want it. That helped a lot, especially considering despite the fact she hadn't been compelled to do this Caroline didn't feel she could stop herself from kissing her way down Bonnie's flat stomach, and not just because her Mistresses had ordered her to do this.
When Caroline settled in between her legs Bonnie whimpered, "Caroline, we can't do this. Think of your boyfriend!"
"He isn't here." Caroline shrugged, "He isn't anywhere near here. And even if he was, I'd rather fuck you."
With that Caroline lowered her head, stuck out her tongue and slid it over Bonnie's pussy lips, making her best friend moan loudly in pleasure. That moan was like the sweetest music to Caroline's ears, the vampire promising herself it wouldn't be the last time she heard the sound. And it wasn't, Caroline making Bonnie moan a lot over the next few minutes, each one louder than the last as she settled into a steady pussy licking, her tongue lapping at the treat in front of her as her taste buds were introduced to one of the best tastes ever, namely cunt cream. Oh Caroline would be forever grateful to her Mistresses for introducing her to the joys of cunt cream.
If it was possible Bonnie might have even tasted better than Elena and Rebekah, and Caroline hadn't thought anything could be better than those pussies. Or maybe it was just because, at least in this moment, Bonnie was her conquest. Oh yes, throughout her 'seduction' Caroline had been very aware that she was being conquered by Rebekah and more importantly Elena, the two other girls making her feel like a total slut. Caroline wondered if that was how Bonnie felt now. She hoped so, as there was nothing in the world quite like it. And she definitely promised herself this wouldn't be the last time she was in between Bonnie's legs.
Bonnie couldn't believe this was actually happening to her. Couldn't believe that one of her best friends was now licking her pussy. One of her female best friends was licking her pussy, and it felt good. So incredibly good, the way her body reacted to the female touch telling Bonnie she wasn't as straight as she had always believed. And sure, she had the occasional gay thought, but the thousands of magazines that Caroline brought, and she sometimes purchased as a guilty pleasure, told her that was normal and didn't mean anything. Besides, her two best female friends had grown into such beautiful young women it seemed only natural she would be a little attracted to them, just as it felt normal to be a tiny bit drawn to the other hot women surrounding her.
However up until now Bonnie had never seriously considered being with another woman, and she certainly never considered making a move on such a close female friend like Caroline Forbes. Mostly because it would ruin their friendship, although as long as Bonnie had known her Caroline had been completely boy crazy so naturally she had never thought that she would be into something like this. And now the boy crazy blonde was seducing her! Eating her pussy like a greedy lesbian slut! Oh God, what had Elena done to her?
Elena! Just the thought of her name caused Bonnie to open her eyes wide and whimper. When did she close her eyes? Bonnie wasn't sure, she was probably overwhelmed by the pleasure she was feeling, which was weird because Caroline was still just gently lapping away at her pussy lips with a determination which none of her previous boyfriends had come close to, and yet these simple licks were making her feel this way? How was that possible? And how was Bonnie allowing herself to become so distracted when she should be focusing on the person responsible for this, the now evil vampire who had manipulated her best friend into fucking her... and was responsible for the wonderful pleasure she was now receiving.
Bonnie knew she should be putting a stop to this. This was wrong. Lesbianism and experimentation was fine for some girls, but no matter how good it felt it wasn't her. Besides, mentally she was still in a relationship with Jeremy, and she wasn't a slut who had sex with just anyone at a drop of a hat. Most importantly she couldn't let emotionless Elena win. And yet she just couldn't convince herself to push Caroline away, or to render her helpless with a spell, or anything except lay back and moan, groan, whimper and cry out as Caroline continued licking her cunt with surprising skill.
Caroline still couldn't believe how good pussy tasted. Part of her wondered if Bonnie had enchanted her cunt to taste extra sweet or perhaps even Mistress Rebekah had compelled her to think the witch's pussy tasted like liquid heaven or something like that, because she found the taste more addictive with every single lick. Whatever the explanation, she was just glad to find herself in between another girl's legs sampling her most precious gift. And this wasn't just any girl, this was her other best friend Bonnie Bennett, and if Caroline played her cards right she could be regularly going down on both her childhood best friend's, eating their little pussies and sexually pleasing them in every way possible.
She had never thought of such a twisted idea before catching her Mistresses together, but now it was all she could think of, Caroline desperately wanting to help Bonnie transition from broken-hearted heterosexual to raving homosexual who got to indulge in wonderful sexual acts with her two best friends. And whoever else Mistress Elena wanted them to fuck. Oh Mistress Elena, just the thought of her name, and Mistress Rebekah's name, cause Caroline to quiver in delight. She so desperately wanted to please them, to help them put Bonnie in her place and turn her into a sub willing to please the dominant Alpha females that were Elena Gilbert and Rebekah Mikaelson.
In the name of that Caroline forced herself to just gently lick Bonnie's pussy for what felt like a very long time, however the second she pushed her tongue into her friend she lost control completely. She might have taken the second to enjoy the feeling of Bonnie's cunt quivering around her tongue, then Caroline started hammering her tongue in and out of her best friend, making the other girl writhed beneath her touch and cry out in pure pleasure. After half a dozen thrusts of Caroline's tongue Bonnie even reached down to grab two handfuls of blonde hair and pulled it deeper into her love box, the white girl smiling against the black girl's pussy as she continued frantically tongue fucking it.
Her Mistresses had told Caroline she lacked skill when it came to eating pussy, but what she lacked in experience she made up for in enthusiasm. As such maybe it was for the best she started pounding Bonnie's pussy the second she got her tongue inside it. Truthfully she didn't regret it as it caused Bonnie's honey to become even more plentiful, and it wasn't long before Caroline's mouth was filled with the cum of her other best friend, her eyelids fluttering as she struggled to swallow everything Bonnie had to give her. Oh how she wanted to tongue fuck Bonnie and drink her cum all night long, however that wasn't the plan, and if Caroline didn't follow the plan she wouldn't get rewarded. More to the point it would displease Mistress Elena and Mistress Rebekah, and Caroline couldn't bear the thought of displeasing her Mistresses.
Bonnie was completely overwhelmed by the force of her orgasms. She hadn't even cum more than once during sex before, and these climaxes were more powerful so that when they ganged up on her she thought she would literally explode. Which should have been an absurd thought, but with everything else she'd experienced lately it didn't seem that far-fetched. Which was scary, but she was happy to meet her maker if it meant she could experience more of this wonderful ecstasy. Unfortunately just as that thought when through her mind Caroline pulled away from her completely and zipped off using her super speed, leaving Bonnie with barely enough time to whimper before she returned.
Instead of returning to what she had been doing Caroline pushed her ass up and slipped something underneath it, Bonnie shock to realise her best friend was attaching a strap-on to her, Caroline even spitting onto her hand and rubbing it into the shaft before finally looking at her, "Trust me."
Bonnie wasn't entirely sure whether that was a statement or a question, but either way Caroline swiftly got on top of her, lined up the dildo with the entrance to her pussy and then pushed herself downwards, the beautiful blonde moaning as her little cunt not only took the head of that large toy but quickly swallowed the rest of it until Caroline was sitting on her lap with every inch of that fake cock inside her. She didn't exactly take it with ease, Caroline's face twisting with pain and pleasure as she was no doubt stretched obscenely wide, but that expression melted into one of pure pleasure shortly after Caroline took the entire length inside her and then started bouncing up and down on Bonnie's strap-on.
Her strap-on? Technically it wasn't hers, Bonnie had no idea where Caroline had even retrieve this object from, however she didn't think it was a coincidence that the dildo perfectly matched her dark skin tone, the attention to detail on the toy almost making it look like Bonnie had grown a real penis. Was that possible? Could she do a spell and temporally turn her cunt into a cock and know what it was really like to be inside another girl? And why was she thinking such things? She was straight, and in love with a man she was determined to get back, and... God there was such an obscene beauty to watching Caroline's pale little body against her, bouncing on top of her, that white pussy taking every inch of her black cock, Bonnie honestly not knowing whether she should look at the happy look on Caroline's face, her stretched cunt or her little white titties bouncing up and down with each thrust.
Bonnie was captivated for a few long moments, then she heard a horribly familiar voice. Specifically, Elena's voice, "See Rebekah, I knew our little slut could do it."
Slowly following her girlfriend into the room Rebekah huffed, "Well, they're not my friends. But I have to admit, I'm surprised Bonnie turned out to be so easy. And that Caroline didn't fuck up."
Elena shrugged, "Bonnie just loves a little attention. She's so used to being ignored in favour of me and Caroline that she'll normally take what she can get. Why do you think she settled for my brother?"
"HEY!" Bonnie protested as what was left of her friend laughed softly.
"Oh please Bonnie, you know you can do better." Elena pointed out, before turning back to Rebekah, "And as for Caroline, she knows her place now and just wants to please us, don't you Care?"
"Oh yes Mistress Elena." Caroline said eagerly, looking over her shoulder, "I'm your bitch."
"WHAT! You're, you're her what? Mistress Elena? What? I... I..." Bonnie stammered, before exclaiming, "What the hell is going on?"
"Isn't it obvious?" Rebekah queried, "Elena and I have turned Caroline into our little dyke slut. And you're next."
"But we're not going to force you." Elena added quickly before Bonnie could start throwing her powers around, "We're not going to have too, you'll beg to be our little lesbian bitch of your own free will."
As she was in a state of shock it took a few seconds for Bonnie to say anything, and when the words finally came out they didn't sound nearly as confident as she wanted them too, "Oh... and why the hell would I do that?"
"Because we'll give you Caroline, as a gift." Rebekah promised, before beginning to explain, "Elena tells me that you fancy her quite a bit, but you're not really aware of it. That's why we came up with this plan, to show you how much you want this little bitch, and as far as I'm concerned you can have her. You can be little cunt munching dykes together for all I care, as long as you'll submit to us and do whatever we say. Which doesn't sound too bad, does it? Just think, three yummy pussies to eat instead of one, and if you're really good we'll give you the same treat we're about to give Caroline here."
"And what treat is that Caroline?" Elena grinned.
With a dreamy smile on her face Caroline explained, "Mistress Elena and Mistress Rebekah are going to use you to make me air tight. Oh God, mmmmmmmmmm, my wonderful Mistresses are going to strap on some nice big dildos and take turns with my ass and mouth, spit roast me while I keep riding you so that each and every one of my holes are stuffed with cock."
Again Bonnie was shocked into silence for a few long seconds, not just by the words but by the way Caroline touched herself and seemed so enthusiastic for such an unspeakable act, then the Witch finally told her friend, "Caroline, listen very carefully to me, you're not yourself-"
"Wrong!" Caroline interrupted, "This IS the real me Bon. I'm a slut, and I'm so grateful for Mistress Elena and Mistress Rebekah teaching me that."
"Listen to yourself!" Bonnie protested, "You're being compelled!"
"Actually I only had Rebekah compel Caroline not to leave and not to warn you. Everything else she did of her own volition." Elena explained.
"I don't believe you." Bonnie spat.
"That's fair." Elena shrugged, "You don't trust us, and you shouldn't. Not yet. But if you don't give us a chance to earn that trust, I'm going to go outside and kill the first person I see. Do you really want that blood on your hands Bonnie? Especially when all I'm asking is you stay still and get a close-up view at the perks of being one of our pets."
Rebekah allowed that to sink in, then she added, "Besides, do you really want to rob Caroline here of her reward?"
Realising what was expected of her Caroline looked her friend in the eye and shamelessly begged, "Oh please Bonnie, please don't deny me my reward. I wanted so bad. Mmmmmmmm, I love being DP'ed and spit roasted by Mistress Elena and Mistress Rebekah, but I want to know what it's like to be air tight. Ooooooooh yesssssssssss, please don't go yet. If you go, only two of my holes will be fucked, mmmmmmmmmm, and I want all three of my holes filled and pounded like the total slut I am! Ohhhhhhhhhh please Bonnie, please, please, please, please, let me have my reward. Let me be fucked by three cocks at once while your cum is drying on my face."
Unable, or at least unwilling, to believe what she was hearing Bonnie parted her lips to insist Caroline was being compelled. Or Rebekah had forced her to turn off her humanity, leaving her a shell of her former self, just like Elena. However for whatever reason, and she really, really didn't want to explore why, Bonnie didn't do that. Nor did she use her magic to attack the minds of these three vampires and then grab her clothes and leave. And possibly taking what was left of Caroline with her. Instead she just laid there as Caroline grinded on her cock, patiently waiting for her Mistresses to join them.
Elena was first, a Katherine-like smirk on her face as she slowly stripped herself naked, retrieved a strap-on and pulled it up her thighs before kneeling behind Caroline while addressing Bonnie, "You know Bon, growing up you two were always so important to me. We were always so close, but now we'll be closer than ever before. Doesn't that sound like fun?"
"Fuck you!" Bonnie spat, her eyes tearing up even as her heart hammered with excitement.
"Oh Bonnie... that's the idea." Elena mocked while she pulled the plug out of the blonde's butt and then spread one of Caroline's ass cheeks with one hand while using the other hand to guide her dildo against her bitch's still slightly open back hole, "But first, I'm going to fuck Caroline. I'm going to fuck her right up her tight little ass! Oooooooooooh yeah, time to make a sandwich!"
Elena quickly explained that seemingly ridiculous phrase not by words but by actions, specifically by grinning wickedly again and slamming forward, the first few inches of her strap-on easily penetrating Caroline's loosened butt hole and sliding deep into her bottom. It was tempting to use all her strength to see whether she could get every inch in one go up Caroline's ass, and to see whether the perverted slut would actually enjoy that, but as she had only taken Caroline's anal cherry a few hours ago Elena decided to take pity on her former friend. Besides, she was genuinely trying to entice Bonnie to join them of her own free will, and having Caroline screaming in pain would be counter-productive.
Instead Caroline squealed and pleasure, then begged, "Ooooooooohhhhhhhhh Gooooooooodddddddddd yeeeeeeeeessssssssss, make me a sandwich! Mmmmmmmmmm, turn me into a sandwich, oooooooooh yeahhhhhhhhhh, make me the meat in an all-girl sandwich! Ohhhhhhhhh fuck, I love being double stuffed by two hot girls, mmmmmmmmmm, my slutty holes getting filled with rubber cock, the other girls totally making me their bitch! And that's what's happening now Bonnie! Oooooooooooh yeahhhhhhhhhh, no matter what happens in this moment I'm your bitch! I'm yours, and Mistress Elena's. Ohhhhhhhhhh please Mistress Elena, please fill my whore ass with your cock! I want it so bad, I... I AAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHH FUCKKKKKKKKKKK!"
Happy to oblige Elena pushed inch after inch of strap-on dildo up her friend's ass, Elena's eyes locked onto where that large toy was stretching/entering that usually tiny hole. God, she had become such a sick and twisted pervert. And she loved it, Elena finding another huge bonus to anally penetrating Caroline slowly as she thoroughly enjoyed stuffing inch after inch of dildo into the blonde's butt hole. In fact, she enjoyed it so much she was actually a little disappointed when her thighs bumped against her bitch's butt cheeks, announcing Elena had buried every single inch of her cock in Caroline's ass.
"See Bonnie? Now we're closer than we've ever been." Elena grinned while laying down on Caroline's back so she could get a close up look at the expression on her black friend's face, "Mmmmmmmm yeeeeeeessssssssss, the three of us are pressed together in a sexy sandwich, you and me the pieces of bread while slutty little Careline here is the piece of meat, mmmmmmmm, isn't this special? Because honestly, I've never felt... closer to you than I do right now."
"You three have certainly never looked better." Rebekah chuckled softly, "But what would make it even better is if you got on with it and fucked that little tramp. Come on, fuck Caroline in both her cunt and arse at the same time, just the way she likes."
"Ohhhhhhhhhhhhhh yesssssssssss, mmmmmmmmm fuck me! Fuck both my holes!" Caroline cried out eagerly, "Please fuck my pussy and ass at the same time like the nasty little slut I am! Mmmmmmmmm, I love it so much, please double fuck me nice and hard, so we can really get this all-girl sandwich underway."
"You see Bonnie?" Elena grinned, "She's so eager for it."
"Yeah she is." Rebekah laughed.
After sharing that laugh with her girlfriend Elena straightened herself back up, gripped firmly onto Caroline's waist and then began officially butt fucking the submissive blonde. For all the reasons she slowly penetrated Caroline's ass in the first place Elena slowly slid her strap-on in and out of the other girl's widely stretched back hole, the wicked brunette grinning in delight as she became captivated by that obscene sight for several minutes, the whole world fading away as she became obsessed with using Caroline's most private hole as a fuck hole.
In that moment Elena could almost feel her humanity turning itself on, because how could she be unemotional right now? She was in a DP with her two oldest female friends. She was butt fucking Caroline Forbes, who was riding a dildo strapped around the waist of Bonnie Bennett. They were a sandwich, with Elena and Bonnie as the pieces of bread and Caroline as the piece of meat in the middle. She and Bonnie were DP'ing Caroline, and Elena didn't think she'd ever been happier or more sexually fulfilled, proving perhaps in the state she was in it wasn't as simple as turning off all her emotions. Perhaps it was simply turning off her humanity? Elena didn't know, and in this wonderful moment, she didn't care.
The only thing Elena cared about was remembering this moment forever, and with a little help maybe that would be possible, "Rebekah sweetie, would you mind taking a few pictures? Cause I don't know about you, but I think this is a real Kodak moment."
"Sure thing love." Rebekah grinned, not really understanding the reference but ignoring it in favour of retrieving the camera and then starting to take pictures.
At first Elena and Caroline posed while Bonnie gave it a sideways glance. The two white girls almost looked like they were in the middle of normal best friend things instead of a DP, unless female friendship had changed dramatically since the last time Rebekah had come close to it, while the black girl had the same dumbfounded look of pleasure on her face since Rebekah had first walked in. Then Elena and Caroline returned to concentrating on the fucking, Rebekah sure to get some close up shots of the expressions on their faces, the dildos pumping in and out of Caroline's fuck holes, and of course a few faraway shots where you could see all three friends piled up together in this classic group sex position.
Rebekah took more than enough shots for anyone in their right mind to be satisfied. Ok, so Elena wasn't in her right mind, but she was confident enough she would be satisfied, so Rebekah used her vampire speed to strip herself naked, strapped on a dildo and pressed herself up against Elena from behind. At first she kissed the back of Elena's neck and grinded her boobs into her girlfriend's back and the cock against Elena's arse, Rebekah briefly considering to chuck the plan aside and stuff her strap-on dick into Elena's arse hole. Now that would be quite the little foursome.
However before she could suggest it Elena purred, "Want a turn, love?"
Amused by Elena's attempt to mimic her accent Rebekah smiled against her girlfriend's neck and softly murmured, "I'd rather fuck your arse, but alright."
"Ok then." Elena said softly, slowly pulling her dildo out of Caroline's ass hole and then gently but forcefully freed herself from Rebekah's grasp, "She's all yours. Or at least, her ass hole is."
For a moment Rebekah considered protesting that it was Elena who she really wanted. That Caroline was fun and all, as was Elena's idea of turning her two former friends into their personal lesbian sluts, but she'd rather have Elena Gilbert all to herself with no one else. Then her eyes locked onto Caroline's bum hole, gaping wide and twitching from the abuse it had just taken, Rebekah licking her lips and shuffling forward automatically. By the time she had her dildo pressing against her target Caroline's vampire healing had begun to kick in, her arse hole slowly closing which inspired Rebekah to slam forward with every ounce of her strength, burying the entire length of the dildo up the other blonde's butt and making Caroline let out a deafening squeal.
That squeal was mostly of pleasure, but just in case Caroline was going to offer up any form of complaint Elena stuffed her strap-on into Caroline's mouth. To be fair this had been the plan anyway, minus Rebekah perhaps entering Caroline's arse a little roughly, but the submissive blonde didn't seem to mind. On the contrary, Caroline sucked greedily at the dick covered in her own ass cream, eventually taking every inch down her throat with Elena's loving encouragement while Rebekah gleefully sodomised the little tart. This officially meant that Caroline was no longer being DP'ed, she was now being made air tight, the massive whore taking a cock in all three available fuck holes, something which couldn't go unaddressed.
"Oh fuck me, that's so hot!" Elena moaned dreamily, "Care, you look so hot with three cocks inside you! Mmmmmmmmm, I'm so proud of you! Ooooooooooh, I am so proud of my little lesbian slut for taking three strap-on dildos inside her! Oh Caroline, you were a boring friend, but you make an excellent submissive dyke bitch!"
"Yeah she does." Rebekah agreed as Caroline had her mouth full at the moment, "Mmmmmmmmm, Caroline is taking it in her pussy, arse and mouth like a good little whore, and Bonnie is next."
Broken from her dreamlike state Elena grinned, "Oooooooohhhhhhhh yeeeeeeeeeessssssssss, mmmmmmmm just think Bonnie, when you submit to me and Rebekah we can start doing this all the time! You and Caroline taking it in turns to get all your holes fucked, mmmmmmmmmm, me and Rebekah using all those fuck holes for our pleasure, aaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhh shit, and if you're good will even let you fuck Caroline's ass during one of these triple stuffing sessions. Mmmmmmmmm, I bet that would be so hot. You and me sharing Caroline's ass and mouth while Rebekah uses her cunt, ooooooooooh, or me on the bottom so you and Rebekah can stuff Caroline's mouth and butt, ohhhhhhhhhhhh maybe even me or Rebekah going in the middle! Oooooooohhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhhhh, I think it would be fun to get all my holes stuffed!"
"I bet you would look so good love." Rebekah moaned, "But let's concentrate on fucking are broken bitch for now. She's clearly loving it."
Rebekah was right. Caroline had thought nothing could be more heavenly than being fucked up the ass, but she had been proven wrong. Then she had thought the height of sexual pleasure was having her pussy and ass taken at the same time, but somehow it was even better to take it in all three of her holes. Sure, she couldn't feel physical pleasure from having her mouth filled with rubber cock, but it added an incredible mental thrill which her imagination could have never done justice to on the rare occasion she had imagined being gang banged by a bunch of muscular men. Of course this was better than taking on a football team or boy band, this was three women with strap-on cocks which would never go soft, the two that were in the dominant position being vampires with supernatural strength.
For what felt like an eternity Caroline didn't get the benefit of that strength but she definitely got the benefit of the stamina, Rebekah and Elena constantly swapping over as they took turns with her ass and mouth. This meant Caroline was constantly cleaning her own ass from a cock, something which the broken blonde loved, especially when whoever was using her mouth pushed their way into her throat and began thrusting in, Elena and Rebekah eventually fucking her face with the same force that they fucked her ass hole with. The only downside was she soon became desperate to cum, and as there was a cock constantly in her mouth it was difficult for her to beg for the privilege of cumming.
Difficult, but not impossible, Caroline eventually crying out during one of the switches, "FUCK ME! FUCK ME HARD! PLEASE MAKE ME CUM! I NEED TO CUM! I NEED TO CUM SOOOOOOOO BAD! PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE POUND ALL OF MY HOLES AND AAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHH FUCKKKKKKKKKKKK! OOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHH GOOOOOOOOOOOODDDDDDDDDD! FUCKKKKKKKKKKK MEEEEEEEEEE MMMMMMMMMMM AAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHH MMMMMMMMFFFFFFFFFF!"
In the blink of an eye Caroline went from having a horrifically empty ass to an ass full of cock, Elena slamming every single inch of her dildo back up Caroline's butt and beginning to sodomise her like never before. It literally felt like Elena was trying to ruin her rectum forever, and it felt like such an indignity would be worth it for the orgasm she was about to receive, Caroline still thinking that moments later as she let out a deafening scream and squirted all over Bonnie's cock. Seconds later Rebekah's ass flavoured cock was stuffing her throat, somehow making her second orgasm even more powerful than the first. Then Rebekah fucked her mouth with the same force Elena was fucking her ass, Caroline struggling to remain conscious as she was well and truly fucked.
"FUCK HER BONNIE!" Elena demanded at the top of her lungs, "POUND OUR BEST FRIEND'S NASTY LITTLE CUNT WHILE I DESTROY CAROLINE'S SLUTTY LITTLE ASS HOLE! FUCK HER! FUCK HER FUCK HER FUCK HER FUCK HER FUCK HER OOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHH YEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSS! THAT'S IT BON, FUCK HER! LET'S ALL FUCK OUR DEAR FRIEND CAROLINE LIKE THE LITTLE SLUT SHE IS, OOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHHH FUCKKKKKKKKKKK! AAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHH SHIT, MMMMMMMMMMM GOOOOOOOOOODDDDDDDDDDD!"
Just when Caroline didn't think it could get any better Bonnie complied with Elena's order and started thrusting upwards. Without having to look at her friend Caroline could tell Bonnie found this incredibly awkward and she didn't possess the physical strength, or the determination, to make this work. However it didn't matter, just the sensation of being officially fucked by three women at the same time, her mouth, pussy and ass being pumped/pounded by cock, two of which were strapped around the waists of her two best female friends ever Bonnie Bennett and Elena Gilbert, oh it was enough to send Caroline into the stratosphere.
In between Caroline's powerful orgasms Elena and Rebekah continued to switch holes, moving at vampire speed so that Caroline barely missed, and Bonnie barely noticed, the change. In fairness she was caught up in the show directly in front of her, Bonnie ashamed of herself for finding it so erotic. Worse still she was a part of it, the inside of the harness rubbing against her clit and the sheer perverseness of helping to demean Caroline in this way causing her to cum indecently hard. Perhaps not as hard as when Caroline had eaten her pussy, but it was still pretty powerful.
Bonnie told herself she was doing this for Caroline, and maybe those people Elena might hurt if she didn't obey, but it was impossible for her to deny she was enjoying it. At least she could no longer see Elena's grinning face, although watching Rebekah brutally using Caroline's mouth as a pussy wasn't much better, both things making her feel scandalised and yet so very horny, the experience ultimately adding to her orgasms. Not that they could compare to the type Caroline was having, the climaxes obviously so powerful Bonnie wasn't surprised when the broken blonde collapsed seemingly unconscious when the evil vampires were finally done with her, although Elena literally pulling Caroline off of Bonnie's dildo and shoving her down next to her had something to do with it.
"Stand up." Elena ordered in a no-nonsense tone, Bonnie only pausing briefly before doing as she was told. Once she was standing in front of her former friend Elena grinned, and then in the blink of an eye used her super speed to untie the harness from around the Witch's waist and brought the toy up to Bonnie's lips, "Suck it."
Again fearing what Elena might do if she disobeyed Bonnie parted her lips, allowing her best friend to push the dildo coated with her other best friend's cum and pussy cream into her mouth. Elena gave her about a minute to savour the taste, then she started gently fucking Bonnie's mouth, the black girl trying to relax best she could as the white girl added an additional inch with every thrust, the smirking vampire eventually pushing that cock down her throat. Oh how Bonnie wanted to smack that smirk off of her former friend's face, but instead she just allowed Elena to do whatever she wanted while desperately trying to pretend Caroline's cum and pussy juice wasn't the best thing she'd ever tasted.
When it became obvious Bonnie was struggling with the last few inches Elena began taunting, "Mmmmmmm yeah, suck it Bonnie! Suck Caroline's cum right off of that cock! Ooooooooooh, you like the taste of girl cum you little dyke? Can you tell the difference between that an Caroline's equally yummy cunt cream? Well don't worry, because soon you'll be a part of an all-you-can-eat pussy buffet. Mmmmmmmm yesssssssss, you're going to have plenty of time to think about the difference when me and Rebekah are passing your mouth back and forth, and of course you'll have plenty of chances to eat Caroline's cunt... but first, I think that you need to taste some ass."
With that Elena pulled the dildo out of Bonnie's mouth and glanced down to the one still strapped between her thighs, causing Bonnie to blush and whimper, "Ewww, no! I'm not doing that!"
"You should!" Caroline said weakly, wincing as Rebekah rolled her over onto her back and thus forced her to put weight on her sore bottom, "I love the taste of ass. Mmmmmmm, going ass to mouth makes me feel like such a little slut."
"Shut up and eat my pussy bitch." Rebekah warned, undoing her harness and mounting Caroline's face, "Oooooooooh yes, get every drop of my cum out of my cunt you little lezzie slut!"
Ignoring the blondes as one greedily gobbled up the cunt offered to her and the other offered up encouragement Elena pointed out, "Relax Bonnie, I'm sure you'll love it. And if you don't, well... just think of all the innocent people you'll be saving. Or would you rather I step outside right now and kill the first family I see?"
Bonnie stared with disbelief at what was left of her friend, her eyes silently pleading for mercy even though she was sure she would get none. Sure enough Elena just stared at her blankly until Bonnie whimpered, lowered her head and then dropped to her knees. Wanting to get this over with she closed her eyes and quickly wrapped her lips around Elena's cock, Bonnie whimpering again as to her horror she found the taste was not nearly as disgusting as she would have thought. Part of her even liked it, which made Bonnie feel like the biggest slut on the planet. Or one of them at least, in that moment Rebekah reminding her of Caroline who had just done an number of unthinkable things.
"Ohhhhhhhhhh Goooooooooddddddddddd yessssssssssss Caroline, fuck me!" Rebekah moaned as she grinded herself down onto Caroline's pretty face, "Tongue fuck my cunt! Ooooooooooh, you really do make a marvellous rug muncher. Mmmmmmmmm, almost as good as Elena... which makes me wonder, are you positive you didn't used to dyke out with each other during sleep overs? Because I have to say, mmmmmmmmm, if Bonnie is half as good at eating pussy as you and Elena nothing will convince me you three weren't fucking like bunnies long before Elena and I got together."
"If only." Elena sighed wistfully, never taking her eyes off of the girl cleaning her cock, "But don't worry Bonnie, I promise you we're going to make up for lost time just as soon as you agree to be my bitch. Mmmmmmmm, mine and Rebekah's. Ohhhhhhhhh, you and Caroline as our little fuck toys who fulfil all our desires, mmmmmmmmmm, but first I want you to clean my cock. And you better do a good job, because as my pet you're going to be tasting Caroline's ass a lot. Ooooooooooooh yes, you're going to taste Caroline's butt all the time. On my cock, on Rebekah's, and straight from the source, your life consumed with tasting the asses and pussies of your fellow lesbian slut and your Mistresses in any way we fucking want!"
Elena love the fact that when she started talking Bonnie looked up at her but then tried to distract herself by beginning to bob her lips up and down that butt flavoured dildo. Even when she finished talking Bonnie kept sucking her cock, Elena loving the feeling of superiority and power from having the other girl on her knees before her and sucking her strap-on as if it was real. Oh it was wonderful, Elena getting to feed her best friend her other best friend's ass, her childhood companion slurping that toy cock so loudly it could be heard over Rebekah's cries of pleasure.
While her eyes were mostly locked onto her black best friend Elena did occasionally look over to where her white best friend was being smothered by her girlfriend's pussy, just thinking that sentence enough to make her smile. The two blondes looked good, and certainly seemed to be having fun, Elena appreciating that Rebekah kept her talking to a minimum so that Elena could be the one mainly providing commentary to the proceedings. Rebekah really was a surprisingly accommodating girlfriend, and Elena felt it was high time to reward her for it. First though Elena pulled her cock out of Bonnie's mouth, removed the toy from around her waist and then leaned down to shove her tongue in the other girl's mouth, tasting her best friend's ass in her other best friend's mouth in the process.
Elena then broke the kiss and whispered in Bonnie's ear, "If you really want too, you can leave now. Or you can stay and know the joy of eating pussy and getting all your holes stuffed by dildo wearing girls. Just know, the offer remains open to you if you choose to leave. Then when you're ready, all you have to do is ask nicely, ideally by returning to this house, dropping to your knees and kissing my feet while begging me for the privilege of being my bitch. If it helps, I had a talk with Rebekah and she promised me your anal cherry seeing as we are besties and all, and I promise you... WHEN I take your anal cherry, I'll be gentle. At least at first."
With that Elena straightened up, got back onto the bed, kissed a very willing Rebekah and asked, "Do you want to swap so I can eat your pussy while I feed Caroline my cunt? Or do you want to be the one cleaning the cum from my pussy?"
Unsurprisingly Rebekah quickly replied, "Ohhhhhhhhh please, give me your pussy Elena. I want your cum!"
Not needing any further encouragement Elena sat down in front of the blondes so that Rebekah could lean down and start lapping away at her pussy. Strap-on fucking was fun but it often made the wearer a little backed up with cum, the juice either staining the inside of the harness, leaking out or covering her downstairs area. This meant there was plenty of cum for first Caroline to clean from Rebekah and then Rebekah to clean from Elena, in both circumstances the giver eagerly moving onto tongue fucking afterwards and swiftly bringing the receiver to orgasm thanks to how aroused they still were from delivering the fucking.
Elena wouldn't have minded if things went the other way, but she was glad she had guessed right that Rebekah would rather give than receive as her reward. It allowed her to watch Bonnie awkwardly get to her feet and just stand there for a few minutes watching the show. And then to Elena's mild disappointment Bonnie started collecting her clothes and awkwardly getting dressed before heading to the door, Elena sad to see her friend go but confident she would be back.
She even stated, "See you soon Bonnie."
Nervously Bonnie looked back at her, then scurried out of the door, leaving the three vampires to celebrate the end of prom night with a nice long lesbian threesome.